diff --git a/changelog/69_UNRELEASED_xxxx-xx-xx.md b/changelog/69_UNRELEASED_xxxx-xx-xx.md
index a885ce33..c0bbaf91 100644
--- a/changelog/69_UNRELEASED_xxxx-xx-xx.md
+++ b/changelog/69_UNRELEASED_xxxx-xx-xx.md
@@ -26,6 +26,7 @@
 ### Recipes
 
 - Fixed that headlines in the recipe description (preparation text) were removed on saving
+- Fixed that the default consume rule was not always applied correctly when a recipe consumed a substituted ingredient (so when having a parent product in the recipe which is currently not in stock itself)
 
 ### Meal plan
 
diff --git a/controllers/StockApiController.php b/controllers/StockApiController.php
index 16ad51f4..e92ef452 100644
--- a/controllers/StockApiController.php
+++ b/controllers/StockApiController.php
@@ -648,7 +648,7 @@ class StockApiController extends BaseApiController
 			$allowSubproductSubstitution = true;
 		}
 
-		return $this->FilteredApiResponse($response, $this->getStockService()->GetProductStockEntries($args['productId'], false, $allowSubproductSubstitution, true), $request->getQueryParams());
+		return $this->FilteredApiResponse($response, $this->getStockService()->GetProductStockEntries($args['productId'], false, $allowSubproductSubstitution), $request->getQueryParams());
 	}
 
 	public function LocationStockEntries(\Psr\Http\Message\ServerRequestInterface $request, \Psr\Http\Message\ResponseInterface $response, array $args)
diff --git a/migrations/0200.sql b/migrations/0200.sql
new file mode 100644
index 00000000..9811b218
--- /dev/null
+++ b/migrations/0200.sql
@@ -0,0 +1,122 @@
+DROP VIEW stock_next_use;
+CREATE VIEW stock_next_use
+AS
+
+/*
+	The default consume rule is:
+	Opened first, then first due first, then first in first out
+	Apart from that products at their default consume location should be consumed first
+
+	This orders the stock entries by that
+	=> Highest "priority" per product = the stock entry to use next
+	=> ORDER BY clause = ORDER BY priority DESC, open DESC, best_before_date ASC, purchased_date ASC
+*/
+
+SELECT
+	(ROW_NUMBER() OVER(PARTITION BY s.product_id ORDER BY CASE WHEN IFNULL(p.default_consume_location_id, -1) = s.location_id THEN 0 ELSE 1 END ASC, s.open DESC, s.best_before_date ASC, s.purchased_date ASC)) * -1 AS priority,
+	s.*
+FROM stock s
+JOIN products p
+	ON p.id = s.product_id
+ORDER BY CASE WHEN IFNULL(p.default_consume_location_id, -1) = s.location_id THEN 0 ELSE 1 END ASC, s.open DESC, s.best_before_date ASC, s.purchased_date ASC;
+
+CREATE TRIGGER stock_next_use_INS INSTEAD OF INSERT ON stock_next_use
+BEGIN
+	INSERT INTO stock
+		(product_id, amount, best_before_date, purchased_date, stock_id,
+		price, open, opened_date, location_id, shopping_location_id, note)
+	VALUES
+		(NEW.product_id, NEW.amount, NEW.best_before_date, NEW.purchased_date, NEW.stock_id,
+		NEW.price, NEW.open, NEW.opened_date, NEW.location_id, NEW.shopping_location_id, NEW.note);
+END;
+
+CREATE TRIGGER stock_next_use_UPD INSTEAD OF UPDATE ON stock_next_use
+BEGIN
+	UPDATE stock
+	SET product_id = NEW.product_id,
+	amount = NEW.amount,
+	best_before_date = NEW.best_before_date,
+	purchased_date = NEW.purchased_date,
+	stock_id = NEW.stock_id,
+	price = NEW.price,
+	open = NEW.open,
+	opened_date = NEW.opened_date,
+	location_id = NEW.location_id,
+	shopping_location_id = NEW.shopping_location_id,
+	note = NEW.note
+	WHERE id = NEW.id;
+END;
+
+CREATE TRIGGER stock_next_use_DEL INSTEAD OF DELETE ON stock_next_use
+BEGIN
+	DELETE FROM stock
+	WHERE id = OLD.id;
+END;
+
+DROP VIEW products_current_substitutions;
+CREATE VIEW products_current_substitutions
+AS
+
+/*
+	When a parent product is not in-stock itself,
+	any sub product (the next based on the default consume rule) should be used
+
+	This view lists all parent products and in the column "product_id_effective" either itself,
+	when the corresponding parent product is currently in-stock itself, or otherwise the next sub product to use
+*/
+
+SELECT
+	-1, -- Dummy
+	p_sub.id AS parent_product_id,
+	CASE WHEN p_sub.has_sub_products = 1 THEN
+		CASE WHEN IFNULL(sc.amount, 0) = 0 THEN -- Parent product itself is currently not in stock => use the next sub product
+			(
+			SELECT x_snu.product_id
+			FROM products_resolved x_pr
+			JOIN stock_next_use x_snu
+				ON x_pr.sub_product_id = x_snu.product_id
+			WHERE x_pr.parent_product_id = p_sub.id
+				AND x_pr.parent_product_id != x_pr.sub_product_id
+			ORDER BY x_snu.priority DESC, x_snu.open DESC, x_snu.best_before_date ASC, x_snu.purchased_date ASC
+			LIMIT 1
+			)
+		ELSE -- Parent product itself is currently in stock => use it
+			p_sub.id
+		END
+	END AS product_id_effective
+FROM products_view p
+JOIN products_resolved pr
+	ON p.id = pr.parent_product_id
+JOIN products_view p_sub
+	ON pr.sub_product_id = p_sub.id
+JOIN stock_current sc
+	ON p_sub.id = sc.product_id
+WHERE p_sub.has_sub_products = 1;
+
+DROP VIEW products_current_price;
+CREATE VIEW products_current_price
+AS
+
+/*
+	Current price per product,
+	based on the stock entry to use next,
+	or on the last price if the product is currently not in stock
+*/
+
+SELECT
+	-1 AS id, -- Dummy,
+	p.id AS product_id,
+	IFNULL(snu.price, plp.price) AS price
+FROM products p
+LEFT JOIN (
+	SELECT
+		product_id,
+		MAX(priority),
+		price -- Bare column, ref https://www.sqlite.org/lang_select.html#bare_columns_in_an_aggregate_query
+	FROM stock_next_use
+	GROUP BY product_id
+	ORDER BY priority DESC, open DESC, best_before_date ASC, purchased_date ASC
+	) snu
+	ON p.id = snu.product_id
+LEFT JOIN products_last_purchased plp
+	ON p.id = plp.product_id;
diff --git a/services/RecipesService.php b/services/RecipesService.php
index 92a49705..1a50a897 100644
--- a/services/RecipesService.php
+++ b/services/RecipesService.php
@@ -87,7 +87,7 @@ class RecipesService extends BaseService
 		{
 			if ($recipePosition->only_check_single_unit_in_stock == 0)
 			{
-				$this->getStockService()->ConsumeProduct($recipePosition->product_id, $recipePosition->recipe_amount, false, StockService::TRANSACTION_TYPE_CONSUME, 'default', $recipeId, null, $transactionId, true, true);
+				$this->getStockService()->ConsumeProduct($recipePosition->product_id_effective, $recipePosition->recipe_amount, false, StockService::TRANSACTION_TYPE_CONSUME, 'default', $recipeId, null, $transactionId, true, true);
 			}
 		}
 
diff --git a/services/StockService.php b/services/StockService.php
index 73024c96..d99f489a 100644
--- a/services/StockService.php
+++ b/services/StockService.php
@@ -821,7 +821,7 @@ class StockService extends BaseService
 		return $returnData;
 	}
 
-	public function GetProductStockEntries($productId, $excludeOpened = false, $allowSubproductSubstitution = false, $ordered = true)
+	public function GetProductStockEntries($productId, $excludeOpened = false, $allowSubproductSubstitution = false)
 	{
 		$sqlWhereProductId = 'product_id = ' . $productId;
 		if ($allowSubproductSubstitution)
@@ -835,14 +835,7 @@ class StockService extends BaseService
 			$sqlWhereAndOpen = 'AND open = 0';
 		}
 
-		$result = $this->getDatabase()->stock_next_use()->where($sqlWhereProductId . ' ' . $sqlWhereAndOpen);
-
-		if ($ordered)
-		{
-			return $result->orderBy('product_id', 'ASC')->orderBy('priority', 'DESC');
-		}
-
-		return $result;
+		return $this->getDatabase()->stock_next_use()->where($sqlWhereProductId . ' ' . $sqlWhereAndOpen);
 	}
 
 	public function GetLocationStockEntries($locationId)
@@ -857,7 +850,7 @@ class StockService extends BaseService
 
 	public function GetProductStockEntriesForLocation($productId, $locationId, $excludeOpened = false, $allowSubproductSubstitution = false)
 	{
-		$stockEntries = $this->GetProductStockEntries($productId, $excludeOpened, $allowSubproductSubstitution, true);
+		$stockEntries = $this->GetProductStockEntries($productId, $excludeOpened, $allowSubproductSubstitution);
 		return FindAllObjectsInArrayByPropertyValue($stockEntries, 'location_id', $locationId);
 	}